《IMD：2025年全球智慧城市指数报告：住房可负担性挑战关切日增（英文版）（175页）.pdf》由会员分享，可在线阅读，更多相关《IMD：2025年全球智慧城市指数报告：住房可负担性挑战关切日增（英文版）（175页）.pdf（175页珍藏版）》请在三个皮匠报告上搜索。

1、2025IMDSmart City IndexThe housing affordability challenge:A growing concern World CompetitivenessCenterWorld CompetitivenessCenter3IMD Smart City Index 2025Table of contentsTable of contents3The housing affordability challenge:A growing concern 5The IMD World Competitiveness Center11User guide12How

2、 to read a profile13Methodology15Sources162025 results17In 2025 city ranking order and 2024 comparison 18City profiles21Abu Dhabi22Abuja23Accra24Algiers25Al-Khobar26AlUla27Amman28Amsterdam29Ankara30Astana31Athens32Auckland33Bangkok34Barcelona35Beijing36Beirut37Belfast38Bengaluru39Berlin40Bilbao41Bir

3、mingham42Bogota43Bologna44Bordeaux45Boston46Brasilia47Bratislava48Brisbane49Brussels50Bucharest51Budapest52Buenos Aires53Busan54Cairo55Canberra56Cape Town57Caracas58Cardiff59Chengdu60Chicago61Chongqing62Copenhagen63Delhi64Denver65Doha66Dubai67Dublin68Dusseldorf69Geneva70Glasgow71Gothenburg72Guangzho

4、u73Guatemala City74Hamburg75Hangzhou76Hanoi77Hanover78Helsinki79Ho Chi Minh City80Hong Kong81Hyderabad82Islamabad83Istanbul84Jakarta85Jeddah86Kiel87Krakow88Kuala Lumpur89Kuwait City90Lagos91Lausanne92Leeds93Lille94Lima95Lisbon96Ljubljana97London98Los Angeles99Luxembourg100Lyon1014IMD Smart City Inde

5、x 2025Madrid102Makassar103Manama104Manchester105Manila106Marseille107Mecca108Medan109Medellin110Medina111Melbourne112Mexico City113Milan114Montreal115Mumbai116Munich117Muscat118Nairobi119Nanjing120New York121Newcastle122Nicosia123Osaka124Oslo125Ottawa126Paris127Philadelphia128Phoenix129Prague130Raba

6、t131Reykjavik132Riga133Rio de Janeiro134Riyadh135Rome136Rotterdam137San Francisco138San Jos139San Juan140Sanaa141Santiago142Sao Paulo143Seattle144Seoul145Shanghai146Shenzhen147Singapore148Sofia149Stockholm150Sydney151Taipei City152Tallinn153Tel Aviv154The Hague165Tokyo156Toronto157Tunis158Vancouver1

7、59Vienna160Vilnius161Warsaw162Washington D.C.163Wellington164Zagreb165Zaragoza166Zurich167Table of contentsAnnex168In alphabetical order by city and 2024 comparison 169In alphabetical order by country with HDI context1725IMD Smart City Index 2025IMD Smart City Index 2025The housing affordability cha

8、llenge:A growing concern 6IMD Smart City Index 20252025 has barely gotten underway and yet significant trade tensions,policy shifts,and weakened business and consumer confidence appear to have set the tone for the year.The aggressive trade stance adopted by the United States which notably includes s

9、ubstantial tariff hikes on imports from China,Mexico,and Canada has,as we know,triggered retaliatory measures,re-escalating trade wars.In 2018,during his first term,President Trump started increasing tariffs on goods from China-first on“only”8%of Chinese exports but covering over 66%by early 2020.Wh

10、ile the extent,magnitude,and duration of current tariff increases remain uncertain,past lessons from the 2018 US-China trade war suggest that the direct participants will all experience economic losses(Caliendo and Parro,2023),while the impact on other economies will be more difficult to predict;the

11、re may be some winners especially in Southeast Asia where production can be more easily relocated(Fajgelbaum et al.,2024).Inflationary pressures remain a concern,particularly in industries heavily reliant on imported materials,such as construction.Higher tariffs on steel(and potentially lumber)are e

12、xpected to increase development costs,putting further stress on an already-constrained housing supply.The housing affordability challenge:A growing concern Making housing more affordable is the top priority for most of the respondents of the 2025 IMD Smart City Survey.In 110 out of 146 cities,afford

13、able housing is mentioned as a priority by at least half of the respondents in the city.The issue is particularly felt in Dublin or Vancouver,where about 90%of the IMD Smart City Survey respondents expressed concern over housing affordability.Respondents in the Middle East agree:about 80%of responde

14、nts from AlUla or Dubai identify affordable housing as a priority area.In a deglobalized world where countries seem more out for their own interests than in the recent memorable past,we remain united by the issue of affordable housing.DublinSan FranciscoReykjavikMunichThe HagueGenevaBelfastAmsterdam

15、Taipei CityHong KongAbu DhabiTel AvivCape TownWarsawKrakowNicosiaRigaShenzhenMedellinBuenos AiresHangzhouHyderabadTunisBucharestMedan0102030405060708090100(%)Figure 1.Percentage of respondents identifying affordable housing as a priority areaPercentageAverageHousing has become increasingly unafforda

16、ble for many households over the past couple of years.According to IMF data,it is currently less affordable than during the house price bubble that preceded the 2007-08 global financial crisis(Biljanovska et al.,2023).This harsh statistic is reflected in the responses in the IMD Smart City Survey:in

17、 cities as far apart geographically as Lisbon,Vancouver,Dublin,and Reykjavik some nine in 10 respondents report difficulties finding housing that costs less than a third of their income.Conversely,in Chinese cities such as Guangzhou(a Tier 1 city)and Hangzhou and Chongqing(both new Tier 1 cities),pe

18、rceptions of affordability are significantly more optimistic:just three in 10 respondents report difficulties finding housing that costs less than a third of their income.However,this finding needs to be viewed in the context of Chinas ongoing real estate downturn.In 2020,China introduced measures t

19、o curb excessive leverage in real estate and de-risk the sector.Stalled projects and liquidity shortages led to defaults by major developers like Evergrande and Country Garden,further deepening the sectors slump.Despite efforts to stabilize the market through public investments and interest rate cut

20、s,business and consumer confidence remains low,far below pre-pandemic levels.7IMD Smart City Index 2025Rising interest rates,persistent inflation,and elevated energy costs have priced large segments of the population out of both homeownership and rental markets.A major driver of rising housing costs

21、 is the imbalance between supply and demand.Restrictive zoning laws and regulatory barriers have contributed to high housing costs in countries such as the US(Glaeser et al.,2005),the UK(Hilber and Vermuelen,2016),and other OECD countries(Caldera and Johansson,2013).This evidence is echoed in our da

22、ta:over 70%of respondents from an American or a British city list housing as a priority area.Moreover,about eight in ten respondents in San Francisco,Denver,Seattle,Boston,Cardiff,or Glasgow report that finding housing that costs less than a third of their income is problematic.The rapid growth of u

23、rban populations and demographic shifts have further intensified demand pressures.The affordability“crisis”as it has come to be called is no longer limited to low-income households,but it is increasingly affecting the middle classes.Brueckner and Rosenthal(2009)underscore the cyclical nature of gent

24、rification and neighborhood evolution,highlighting how rising costs can lead to displacement and exacerbate wealth inequalities.Respondents in the IMD Smart City Survey who expressed concern about housing affordability also showed apprehension towards the availability of employment and critical serv

25、ices such as healthcare and education.The housing burden is,in addition,constraining labor mobility,leading to a misallocation of workers with potentially severe effects on economic growth(Glaeser and Gyourko,2018).Cities like New York and San Francisco have adopted stringent regulations for new hou

26、sing,de facto making housing affordable only to high-productivity workers able to command higher wages(Hsieh and Moretti,2019).The recent surge in immigration has sparked a debate about the role of immigrants on housing costs.The argument is that when housing supply is constrained(for example,becaus

27、e of stringent regulations),the additional demand for housing by migrants would fuel housing prices.Empirical evidence supports this conjecture:a 1%increase in international immigration translates into a 1%hike in(flat)rental prices(Card,2007 for the US;Unal et al.,2024 for Germany).The effect is la

28、rger when focusing on high-skilled immigrants(Ottaviano and Peri,2012):US states with a higher share of high(rather than low)-skilled migrants witness larger rent increases.Seeing these results through the lenses of our sample would imply that in talent-importing cities,such as Zurich,Geneva,and Dub

29、ai,the inflow of foreign professionals has contributed to rising rental costs and housing shortages.In Dubai,over 40%of the value of all residential property is held by foreign nationals,thanks to a 20%increase between 2020 and 2022 in foreign-owned residential real estate.Conversely,in talent-expor

30、ting cities,such as Mumbai,the outflows of skilled workers ease the pressure on the real estate market.Half of Mumbais respondents find affordable housing problematic a relatively low share compared to other cities.Supply-side constraints and investment-driven speculations may still pose challenges

31、to housing affordability.The COVID-19 pandemic initially caused a sharp decline in downtown residential prices due to increased teleworking and underutilized commercial spaces,but it was short-lived(Duranton and Handbury,2023).However,suburban housing prices surged,which led to a lasting“doughnut ef

32、fect”,where suburbs became preferred over downtown areas by both people and businesses(Ramani and Bloom,2024).These shifts have further reshaped urban housing demand and affordability dynamics.The housing affordability challenge:A growing concern 8IMD Smart City Index 2025Housing affordability is cl

33、osely tied to transportation infrastructure.Expanding access to affordable housing can be achieved by increasing housing density and improving public transport networks.Take London and Brussels,two cities where congestion costs commuters over 110 hours per year(TomTom Traffic Index,2024),and,unsurpr

34、isingly,traffic congestion is perceived as problematic by at least three in four respondents in Brussels or London(IMD Smart City Survey).These citizens lament inadequate public transportation-about two in five respondents in Brussels and one in three in London-and deem bike-hiring or car-sharing as

35、 rather ineffective tools to reduce congestion only about half of respondents find these tools useful,and a similar share of respondents agrees that apps that direct drivers to an available parking space have reduced journey times.City governments play a crucial role in addressing housing challenges

36、 through urban planning and transportation policies.The OECD emphasizes the importance of leveraging local policy tools to enhance housing accessibility and affordability.For instance,investments in efficient public transport can expand viable residential areas,connecting lower-cost suburban regions

37、 with urban job markets(Ewing and Cervero,2010).Additionally,streamlining permitting processes and promoting high-density development could help mitigate supply shortages.The availability of funding both public and private plays a crucial role in housing affordability.Some governments,particularly i

38、n the Middle East,have adopted aggressive strategies to increase supply through massive real estate investments.As part of UAE Vision 2030,significant efforts were made to diversify the economy and prop up the real estate sector.Large-scale residential investments were facilitated by government-back

39、ed initiatives and partnerships with private developers.Dubais housing boom is driven by favorable taxation and ownership regimes,as well as extensive urban planning efforts.Some of these elements,such as incentives for foreign investors,are also behind the expansion of the real estate sector in Man

40、ama,a new entrant in the Smart City Index ranking.For cities struggling with affordability,significant dividends could come from leveraging both public and private capital to develop high-density and support transit-oriented housing.Climate change adds another layer of complexity to the housing cris

41、is In the US,homeowners insurance premiums have increased by 13%,in real terms,between 2020 and 2023(Boomhower et al.,2024).Some insurance companies are no longer offering writing policies in some areas.Climate change is raising insurance premia,as the increased frequency and intensity of natural di

42、sasters have led to higher insurance losses.Rising sea levels,extreme weather events,and natural disasters influence also housing location choices and long-term sustainability.Government interventions,such as constructing sea walls or flood defenses,may unintentionally encourage development in high-

43、risk areas(Hsiao,2023).Increasing transparency over climate-related risks can shape buyer behavior and help prevent undesirable outcomes.Fairweather et al.(2024)find that when homebuyers have access to flood risk data,they tend to favor safer locations and adjust their willingness to pay accordingly

44、.Policies that enhance the acquisition and diffusion of reliable and accessible data can thus pay large dividends.In China,research by Zhang et al.(2016)suggests that simply providing buyers with an information card detailing the benefits of green buildings significantly increases their willingness

45、to invest in sustainable housing.This finding underscores the potential of targeted information campaigns to drive environmentally responsible development without excessive costs.The housing affordability challenge:A growing concern Addressing the housing crisis requires a multipronged approach that

46、 integrates regulatory reforms,economic policy adjustments,and innovative urban planning.Combining infrastructure investments,incentives,and institutional frameworks will help build a more resilient and inclusive housing market(Ashraf,Glaeser,and Ponzetto,2016).Implementing such a broad range of int

47、erventions can be challenging for advanced economies and even more so for emerging markets given their often-limited implementation capacity.However,confronting the crisis by tackling supply constraints,fostering affordability,and incorporating sustainability into housing policies can create more li

48、vable and more inclusive urban environments,delivering positive economic dividends at the same time.9IMD Smart City Index 2025Ashraf,N.,Glaeser,E.L.,&Ponzetto,G.A.(2016).Infrastructure,incentives,and institutions.American Economic Review,106(5),77-82.Biljanovska,N.,Fu,M.C.,&Igan,M.D.O.(2023).Housing

49、 affordability:A new dataset.International Monetary Fund.Boomhower,J.,Fowlie,M.,Gellman,J.,&Plantinga,A.(2024).How are insurance markets adapting to climate change?Risk selection and regulation in the market for homeowners insurance(No.w32625).National Bureau of Economic Research.Bown,C.P.(2021).The

50、 US-China trade war and Phase One agreement.Journal of Policy Modeling,43(4),805-843.Caldera,A.,&Johansson,.(2013).The price responsiveness of housing supply in OECD countries.Journal of Housing Economics,22(3),231-249.Caliendo,L.,&Parro,F.(2023).Lessons from US-China trade relations.Annual Review o

51、f Economics,15(1),513-547.Card,D.(2007).How immigration affects US cities(Vol.11,No.07).CReAM discussion paper.Duranton,G.,&Handbury,J.(2023).Covid and cities,thus far(No.w31158).National Bureau of Economic Research.Fairweather,D.,Kahn,M.E.,Metcalfe,R.D.,&Olascoaga,S.S.(2024).Expecting climate chang

52、e:A nationwide field experiment in the housing market(No.w33119).National Bureau of Economic Research.Fajgelbaum,P.,Goldberg,P.,Kennedy,P.,Khandelwal,A.,&Taglioni,D.(2024).The US-China trade war and global reallocations.American Economic Review:Insights,6(2),295-312.Glaeser,E.L.,Gyourko,J.,&Saks,R.E

53、.(2005).Why have housing prices gone up?American Economic Review,95(2),329-333.Glaeser,E.,&Gyourko,J.(2018).The economic implications of housing supply.Journal of economic perspectives,32(1),3-30.Hilber,C.A.,&Vermeulen,W.(2016).The impact of supply constraints on house prices in England.The Economic

54、 Journal,126(591),358-405.Hsiao,A.(2023).Sea level rise and urban adaptation in Jakarta.Working Paper.Hsieh,C.T.,&Moretti,E.(2019).Housing constraints and spatial misallocation.American economic journal:macroeconomics,11(2),1-39.Ottaviano,Gianmarco I.P.,and Peri,Giovanni(2012).The effects of immigra

55、tion on US wages and rents:a general equilibrium approach In:Nijkamp,Peter and Poot,Jacques and Sahin,Mediha,(eds.)Migration Impact Assessment:New Horizons.Edward Elgar Publishing Limited,Cheltenham,107-146.ISBN 9780857934574 Ramani,A.,&Bloom,N.(2021).The Donut Effect of COVID-19 on Cities(No.w28876

56、).National Bureau of Economic Research.Rogoff,K.S.,&Yang,Y.(2020).Peak China housing(No.w27697).National Bureau of Economic Research.Unal,U.,Hayo,B.,&Erol,I.(2024).The effect of immigration on housing prices:Evidence from 382 German districts.The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,1-39.Zha

57、ng,L.,Sun,C.,Liu,H.,&Zheng,S.(2016).The role of public information in increasing homebuyers willingness-to-pay for green housing:Evidence from Beijing.Ecological Economics,129,40-49.ReferencesThe top 20 cities10IMD Smart City Index 2025Six new cities AlUla,Astana(formerly Nur Sultan),Caracas,Kuwait

58、City,Manama,and San Juan were added to the 2025 Smart City Index(SCI),bringing the total number surveyed from 142 in 2024 to 146 in 2025.Due to a lack of sufficient data,Tianjin and Zhuhai were excluded from the sample considered.The methodology remains consistent over time.The ranking assesses how

59、urban technologies and infrastructure perform in five key areas health and safety,mobility,activities,opportunities,and governance.To ensure accuracy and mitigate the influence of potential outliers,we employ a three-year moving average of residents perceptions along the different issues considered.

60、The SCI is based on the survey responses of residents from a heterogeneous group of cities.To enable comparability across similar environments,responses are calibrated to the local context by incorporating the city-level Subnational Human Development Index(SHDI)from the Global Data Lab.Once again,th

61、e rankings remain stable with minimal shifts among the top 20 cities.The only changes here relative to last year concern Taipei City,which slid from 16th in 2024 to 23rd in 2025,and Ljubljana which jumped from 32nd to 16th.Zurich holds onto the top spot for another year,continuing the existing trend

62、 of strong performances by Swiss cities across all dimensions the SCI evaluates.Middle Eastern cities such as Dubai and Abu Dhabi rose in the 2025 ranking from 12th and 10th position to fourth and fifth,respectively.Zurich Oslo Geneva Dubai Abu Dhabi London Copenhagen Canberra Singapore Lausanne 321

63、65498710Helsinki Prague Seoul Beijing Shanghai Ljubljana Amsterdam Stockholm Hong Kong Hamburg 1312111615141918172011IMD Smart City Index 2025The IMD World Competitiveness Center TeamProfessor Arturo Bris Director Christos CabolisChief Economist&Head of OperationsJos CaballeroSenior EconomistFabian

64、GrimmResearch SpecialistOdete MadureiraWCC CoordinatorWilliam MilnerAssociate DirectorFrancesca de NicolaSenior EconomistChinar SharmaProjects AnalystAlice Tozer Content ManagerFor over thirty years,the IMD World Competitiveness Center has pioneered research on how countries and companies compete to

65、 lay the foundations for sustainable value creation.The competitiveness of nations is probably one of the most significant developments in modern management and IMD is committed to leading thefield.The IMD World Competitiveness Center12IMD Smart City Index 2025IMD Smart City Index 2025User guide13IM

66、D Smart City Index 2025PRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountryNetherlandsHDILife expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanitati

67、on meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance problems provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesAir

68、 pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical services provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to effectively monitor air pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments online

69、 has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing Apps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has made

70、 public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic congestion through mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportunit

71、ies(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are readily availableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find workMost children have access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOnli

72、ne services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBusinesses are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliability meet connectivity needsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public access

73、to city finances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is not an issue of concernOnline voting has increased participationResidents contribute to decision making of local governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResidents provide feedback on l

74、ocal government projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has reduced waiting times(UN World Urbanization Prospects)1,180,0000.964(Global Data Lab)From a list of 15 indicators,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the perc

75、entage of responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.76.355.666.672.1STRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES47.960.255.138.158.169.843.768.027.441.653.6All ratings rangefrom AAA to D17158.2GROUPATECHNOLOGIESAAFACTOR RATINGSAASTRUCTURES59.270.7202081.7+0.003+0.8+0.0+0.044.166.281.820.658.0Amsterdam51.01

76、 yr change12.652,50012.657,278202120220.93982.518.618.6201918 in 2024Out of 146Out of 14274.760.059.952.051.812.50.93381.618.412.60.93661.162.455,355SMART CITY RANKINGA in 202459.745.145.754.473.455.163.456.1SMART CITY RATING+1,92355,6280.93282.018.4You are willing to concede personal data in order

77、to improve traffic congestionYou are comfortable with face recognition technologies to lower crimeYou feel the availability of online information has increased your trust in authoritiesThe proportion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)0204060801000204060801005

78、9.2%61.9%62.7%73.8%0%20%40%60%80%100%of respondents who agree or strongly agree with the statementScore75.5%55.8%39.9%39.2%32.9%32.2%28.4%24.8%23.0%22.6%20.4%17.8%16.0%13.2%10.3%0%20%40%60%80%100%affordable housingsecurityhealth servicespublic transportroad congestionbasic amenities(water,waste)Gree

79、n spacesair pollutionschool educationunemploymentcitizen engagementsocial mobility/inclusivenessrecyclingfulfilling employmentcorruption/transparency%of respondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreGROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:PRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIA

80、TTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountryNetherlandsHDILife expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanitation meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance pr

81、oblems provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesAir pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical s

82、ervices provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to effectively monitor air pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments online has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sha

83、ring Apps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has made public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic conges

84、tion through mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are read

85、ily availableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find workMost children have access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOnline services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBus

86、inesses are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliability meet connectivity needsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public access to city finances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is not an

87、issue of concernOnline voting has increased participationResidents contribute to decision making of local governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResidents provide feedback on local government projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has reduced

88、 waiting times(UN World Urbanization Prospects)1,180,0000.964(Global Data Lab)From a list of 15 indicators,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the percentage of responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.76.355.666.

89、672.1STRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES47.960.255.138.158.169.843.768.027.441.653.6All ratings rangefrom AAA to D17158.2GROUPATECHNOLOGIESAAFACTOR RATINGSAASTRUCTURES59.270.7202081.7+0.003+0.8+0.0+0.044.166.281.820.658.0Amsterdam51.01 yr change12.652,50012.657,278202120220.93982.518.618.6201918 in 2024Out of 14

90、6Out of 14274.760.059.952.051.812.50.93381.618.412.60.93661.162.455,355SMART CITY RANKINGA in 202459.745.145.754.473.455.163.456.1SMART CITY RATING+1,92355,6280.93282.018.4You are willing to concede personal data in order to improve traffic congestionYou are comfortable with face recognition technol

91、ogies to lower crimeYou feel the availability of online information has increased your trust in authoritiesThe proportion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)02040608010002040608010059.2%61.9%62.7%73.8%0%20%40%60%80%100%of respondents who agree or strongly agre

92、e with the statementScore75.5%55.8%39.9%39.2%32.9%32.2%28.4%24.8%23.0%22.6%20.4%17.8%16.0%13.2%10.3%0%20%40%60%80%100%affordable housingsecurityhealth servicespublic transportroad congestionbasic amenities(water,waste)Green spacesair pollutionschool educationunemploymentcitizen engagementsocial mobi

93、lity/inclusivenessrecyclingfulfilling employmentcorruption/transparency%of respondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreGROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:PRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountryNeth

94、erlandsHDILife expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanitation meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance problems provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA website

95、or App allows residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesAir pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical services provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to effectiv

96、ely monitor air pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments online has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing Apps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps that dir

97、ect you to an available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has made public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic congestion through mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnl

98、ine purchasing of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are readily availableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find workMost

99、 children have access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOnline services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBusinesses are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliability meet c

100、onnectivity needsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public access to city finances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is not an issue of concernOnline voting has increased participationResidents contribute

101、to decision making of local governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResidents provide feedback on local government projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has reduced waiting times(UN World Urbanization Prospects)1,180,0000.964(Global Data Lab)

102、From a list of 15 indicators,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the percentage of responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.76.355.666.672.1STRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES47.960.255.138.158.169.843.768.027.441.653.6All rat

103、ings rangefrom AAA to D17158.2GROUPATECHNOLOGIESAAFACTOR RATINGSAASTRUCTURES59.270.7202081.7+0.003+0.8+0.0+0.044.166.281.820.658.0Amsterdam51.01 yr change12.652,50012.657,278202120220.93982.518.618.6201918 in 2024Out of 146Out of 14274.760.059.952.051.812.50.93381.618.412.60.93661.162.455,355SMART C

104、ITY RANKINGA in 202459.745.145.754.473.455.163.456.1SMART CITY RATING+1,92355,6280.93282.018.4You are willing to concede personal data in order to improve traffic congestionYou are comfortable with face recognition technologies to lower crimeYou feel the availability of online information has increa

105、sed your trust in authoritiesThe proportion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)02040608010002040608010059.2%61.9%62.7%73.8%0%20%40%60%80%100%of respondents who agree or strongly agree with the statementScore75.5%55.8%39.9%39.2%32.9%32.2%28.4%24.8%23.0%22.6%20.

106、4%17.8%16.0%13.2%10.3%0%20%40%60%80%100%affordable housingsecurityhealth servicespublic transportroad congestionbasic amenities(water,waste)Green spacesair pollutionschool educationunemploymentcitizen engagementsocial mobility/inclusivenessrecyclingfulfilling employmentcorruption/transparency%of res

107、pondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreGROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:Smart City RankingSmart City Ranking:The Ranking position of the city amongst the 146 cities measured,based upon the Rating and its components.Group:Each city is assigned to one of four groups,based upon its HDI

108、 values.Smart City Rating and Factor Ratings:The Ratings for each city are calculated from the citys performance relative to the other cities within the group.The Methodology section provides the exact procedure for these calculations.The 2024 Ranking and Rating are also shown for the 142 cities inc

109、luded in the last editions index.Background InformationThis section presents the Human Development Index(HDI)at the city level taken from the Global Data Lab,and the population of the city as defined through the United Nations World Urbanization Prospects for the majority of cities,or Eurostat for s

110、ome of Europeancities.It also presents the United Nations HDI(country-level-for the parent economy of a given city)and its four components,as well as the citys position on the map.Please note:for Taipei City only,the data is calculated using the same methodology and comparable data.Priority AreasSum

111、marizes the areas that the respondents perceive as the priority area for their city.From a list of 15 indicators,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.Thetotal bar indicates the percentage of the respondents that included a given area as one

112、of their five choices.The higher the percentage of responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.How to read a profile14IMD Smart City Index 2025Structures and TechnologiesKey survey data collected on Structures(left side)and Technologies(right side),under five key areas:health and safety

113、,mobility,activities,opportunities,and governance.Each indicator presents the Score for the city and a comparison with its Group(1-4).Showing the Groups Minimum,Mean,and Maximum Scores(green bar)alongside with the city(blue circle)allows a clear comparison of the citys performance in this indicator.

114、The Methodology section provides the exact calculation oftheScore.This table can be read in two ways:down to examine all Structures or Technologies indicators,or across to examine a key area in both Structures andTechnologies.AttitudesShows and compares the responses to three key privacy aspects(wil

115、lingness to concede personal data,comfort vis-vis face recognition,and whether online information has increased trust in authorities)and the percentage of day-to-day transactions that are non-cash.The city is represented by the blue bar,while the group average is shown by the green bar.PRIORITY AREA

116、SBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountryNetherlandsHDILife expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanitation meets the needs of the poorest ar

117、easOnline reporting of city maintenance problems provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesAir pollution is not a problemCCTV came

118、ras has made residents feel saferMedical services provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to effectively monitor air pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments online has improved accessMobilityMobility

119、Traffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing Apps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has made public transport easier to useThe c

120、ity provides information on traffic congestion through mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&S

121、chool)Employment finding services are readily availableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find workMost children have access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOnline services provided by the city has

122、 made it easier to start a new businessBusinesses are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliability meet connectivity needsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public access to city finances has reduced corrupt

123、ionCorruption of city officials is not an issue of concernOnline voting has increased participationResidents contribute to decision making of local governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResidents provide feedback on local government projectsProcessing I

124、dentification Documents online has reduced waiting times(UN World Urbanization Prospects)1,180,0000.964(Global Data Lab)From a list of 15 indicators,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the percentage of responses per area,the gre

125、ater the priority for the city.76.355.666.672.1STRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES47.960.255.138.158.169.843.768.027.441.653.6All ratings rangefrom AAA to D17158.2GROUPATECHNOLOGIESAAFACTOR RATINGSAASTRUCTURES59.270.7202081.7+0.003+0.8+0.0+0.044.166.281.820.658.0Amsterdam51.01 yr change12.652,50012.657,278202120

126、220.93982.518.618.6201918 in 2024Out of 146Out of 14274.760.059.952.051.812.50.93381.618.412.60.93661.162.455,355SMART CITY RANKINGA in 202459.745.145.754.473.455.163.456.1SMART CITY RATING+1,92355,6280.93282.018.4You are willing to concede personal data in order to improve traffic congestionYou are

127、 comfortable with face recognition technologies to lower crimeYou feel the availability of online information has increased your trust in authoritiesThe proportion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)02040608010002040608010059.2%61.9%62.7%73.8%0%20%40%60%80%100

128、%of respondents who agree or strongly agree with the statementScore75.5%55.8%39.9%39.2%32.9%32.2%28.4%24.8%23.0%22.6%20.4%17.8%16.0%13.2%10.3%0%20%40%60%80%100%affordable housingsecurityhealth servicespublic transportroad congestionbasic amenities(water,waste)Green spacesair pollutionschool educatio

129、nunemploymentcitizen engagementsocial mobility/inclusivenessrecyclingfulfilling employmentcorruption/transparency%of respondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreGROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:PRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design C

130、C BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountryNetherlandsHDILife expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanitation meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance problems provides a speedy solutionRec

131、ycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesAir pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical services provision is satisfactoryA w

132、ebsite or App allows residents to effectively monitor air pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments online has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing Apps have reduced congestionPub

133、lic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has made public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic congestion through mobile phonesActivities

134、ActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are readily availableOnline access to job li

135、stings has made it easier to find workMost children have access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOnline services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBusinesses are creating new jobsThe cur

136、rent internet speed and reliability meet connectivity needsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public access to city finances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is not an issue of concernOnline voting has in

137、creased participationResidents contribute to decision making of local governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResidents provide feedback on local government projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has reduced waiting times(UN World Urbanization

138、 Prospects)1,180,0000.964(Global Data Lab)From a list of 15 indicators,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the percentage of responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.76.355.666.672.1STRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES47.960.25

139、5.138.158.169.843.768.027.441.653.6All ratings rangefrom AAA to D17158.2GROUPATECHNOLOGIESAAFACTOR RATINGSAASTRUCTURES59.270.7202081.7+0.003+0.8+0.0+0.044.166.281.820.658.0Amsterdam51.01 yr change12.652,50012.657,278202120220.93982.518.618.6201918 in 2024Out of 146Out of 14274.760.059.952.051.812.50

140、.93381.618.412.60.93661.162.455,355SMART CITY RANKINGA in 202459.745.145.754.473.455.163.456.1SMART CITY RATING+1,92355,6280.93282.018.4You are willing to concede personal data in order to improve traffic congestionYou are comfortable with face recognition technologies to lower crimeYou feel the ava

141、ilability of online information has increased your trust in authoritiesThe proportion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)02040608010002040608010059.2%61.9%62.7%73.8%0%20%40%60%80%100%of respondents who agree or strongly agree with the statementScore75.5%55.8%3

142、9.9%39.2%32.9%32.2%28.4%24.8%23.0%22.6%20.4%17.8%16.0%13.2%10.3%0%20%40%60%80%100%affordable housingsecurityhealth servicespublic transportroad congestionbasic amenities(water,waste)Green spacesair pollutionschool educationunemploymentcitizen engagementsocial mobility/inclusivenessrecyclingfulfillin

143、g employmentcorruption/transparency%of respondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreGROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:How to read a profile15IMD Smart City Index 20251The IMD Smart City Index 2025 assesses the perceptions of residents on issues related to structures and technology appli

144、cations available to them in their city.2This edition of the SCI ranks 146 cities worldwide by capturing the perceptions of 120 residents in each city.The final score for each city is computed by using the perceptions of the last three years of the survey,with the weight of 3:2:1 for 2025:2024:2023.

145、3There are two pillars for which perceptions from residents are solicited:The Structures pillar referring to the existing infrastructure of the cities,and the Technology pillar describing the technological provisions and services available to the inhabitants.4Each pillar is evaluated over five key a

146、reas:health and safety,mobility,activities,opportunities,and governance.5The cities are distributed into four groups based on the Global Data Labs Subnational Human Development Index(SHDI)score of the city they are part of.6Within each SHDI group,cities are assigned a rating scale(AAA to D)based on

147、the perceptions-score of a given city compared to the scores of all other cities within the same group.For group 1(highest SHDI quartile),scaleAAAAAABBB BBFor group 2(second SHDI quartile),scaleABBB BBB CCC For group 3(third SHDI quartile),scaleBBB CCCCCC For group 4(lowest SHDI quartile),scale CCCC

148、CCD7Rankings are then presented in two formats:an overall ranking(1 to 146)a rating for each pillar and overallMethodology16IMD Smart City Index 2025SourcesThe SCI is derived from survey responses collected from residents of participating cities.To encourage the comparability of results across diver

149、se global contexts,these responses are calibrated using the region-level Subnational Human Development Index(SHDI),provided by the Global Data Lab.In addition,data on city population is included for context,although it is not factored into the rankings or ratings.Population figures are sourced from

150、the UNs World Urbanization Prospects,Eurostat,or,when necessary,the respective national census authority.17IMD Smart City Index 2025IMD Smart City Index 2025Results18IMD Smart City Index 2025Vienna26AAA233Riyadh27BBBBBB252Warsaw28BBBAA3810Bilbao29AABBB29Wellington30AABB282Luxembourg31AABBB274Sydney3

151、2AAA2210Doha33BBBBBB4815Vilnius34BBBAA4713Boston35ABBBBBB361Manama36BBBBBBNEWBerlin37ABBBBBB37Madrid38BBBBBA353Mecca39BBBBBB5213Gothenburg40BBBBBBBB391Rotterdam41BBBBBBBB41Ottawa42ABBBB464The Hague43BBBBBBBBB421Melbourne44BBBBBBBB3311Dusseldorf45BBBBBBBB441Riga46BBBBBBBBB5913Jeddah47BBBBB558Brussels

152、48BBBBBA408New York49BBBBBBBB3415Shenzhen50CCCCCCCCC6010CitySmart City Rank 2025Smart City Rating 2025Structure 2025Technology 2025Smart City Rank 2024ChangeZurich1AAAAAAAAA1Oslo2AAAAAAAAA2Geneva3AAAAAAAAA41Dubai4AAA128Abu Dhabi5AAA105London6AAAAAAAA82Copenhagen7AAAAAAAA61Canberra8AAAAAAA35Singapore

153、9AAAAAAAAA54Lausanne10AAAAAAA73Helsinki11AAAAAA92Prague12AAAAAA153Seoul13BBBAAAAA174Beijing14BBBBBB131Shanghai15BBBBBB194Ljubljana16AAAAAA3216Amsterdam17AAAAA181Stockholm18AAAAA117Hong Kong19BBBAAAA201Hamburg20AAABBB146Reykjavik21AAAA265Tallinn22AAA242Taipei City23AAA167Munich24AAA213Auckland25AAAA3

154、16CitySmart City Rank 2025Smart City Rating 2025Structure 2025Technology 2025Smart City Rank 2024ChangeIMD Smart City Index 2025:ResultsIn 2025 city ranking order and 2024 comparison19IMD Smart City Index 2025Brisbane51BBBBBBBB3021Zaragoza52BBBBBBBBB575Vancouver53BBBBBBB4310Hangzhou54CCCCCCCCC6410Gu

155、angzhou55CCCCCCCCC6510Seattle56BBBBBBB637Bratislava57BBBBBBB561Nanjing58BBB624Hanover59ABBBB536Busan60BBBA4515Al-Khobar61BBB9938Washington D.C.62BBBBBB5012Toronto63BBBBBBB5112Manchester64BBBBBBB717Kuala Lumpur65BBB738Dublin66BBBBBBB693Medina67CCCBB747Denver68BBBBBB662Chongqing69CCCCCCCCC8213Krakow70

156、BBB766Paris71BBBBA4922Leeds72BBBBB72Lyon73BBBBB6112Kiel74BBBBBCCC795Newcastle75BBBCCC772Chengdu76CCCCCCCCC9317Bordeaux77BBCCC707Bucharest78CCCBBBBB10022Chicago79BBBBB6712Birmingham80BBB833Montreal81BBBCCC801San Francisco82BBBB757Bologna83BBBB785Budapest84CCCBBBB895Zagreb85BBB10217Bangkok86CCCCCB842M

157、uscat87CCCCCCCCC881Hanoi88CCCCCCCCC979Cardiff89BCCCCC923Kuwait City90CCCCCCBNEWLos Angeles91BBBB6823Barcelona92CCCBBB8111Lille93CCCCCCCCC858Belfast94CCCCCCCC1017Glasgow95BCCCCCC878Tel Aviv96BCCCB942Milan97CCCCCCBB916Ankara98CCCCCCCCC962Osaka99BBCCCCCC954Philadelphia100CCCCCCCCC9010CitySmart City Ran

158、k 2025Smart City Rating 2025Structure 2025Technology 2025Smart City Rank 2024ChangeCitySmart City Rank 2025Smart City Rating 2025Structure 2025Technology 2025Smart City Rank 2024ChangeIMD Smart City Index 2025:ResultsIn 2025 city ranking order and 2024 comparison20IMD Smart City Index 2025Ho Chi Min

159、h City101CCCCCCCC1054Astana102CCCCCCCNEWJakarta103CCCCCCCC103Delhi104CCCCCCC1062Phoenix105CCCCCC987Mumbai106CCCCCC1071Marseille107CCCCCCCCC1043Tokyo108BBBBBB8622Hyderabad109CCCCCCC1112Bengaluru110CCCCCC1091Istanbul111CCCCCC1101AlUla112CCCCCCNEWMedan113CCCCCC1121Makassar114CCCCCC1151Lisbon115CCCCCC10

160、87Islamabad116CCCCCC116Cairo117CCCCC1143Medellin118CCCCCC1191Mexico City119CCCCC1223Santiago120CCCCC1173Sofia121CCCCC1138Nicosia122CCCC1184Rabat123CCCC1263Cape Town124CCC1295Manila125CCC1214San Jos126CCCC1251Amman127CCC1281Algiers128CCC1244Athens129CCCCCCCCC1209Brasilia130CCC130Buenos Aires131CCC123

161、8San Juan132CCCNEWAbuja133CCD1352Bogota134CCC1277Lagos135CCD1361Nairobi136DDC1315Sao Paulo137DDC1325Lima138CCC1344Rome139CCCCCCCCC1336Caracas140DDDNEWAccra141DDD1383Tunis142DDD1375Beirut143DDD1403Guatemala City144DDD1422Sanaa145DDD1414Rio de Janeiro146DDD1397CitySmart City Rank 2025Smart City Rating

162、 2025Structure 2025Technology 2025Smart City Rank 2024ChangeCitySmart City Rank 2025Smart City Rating 2025Structure 2025Technology 2025Smart City Rank 2024ChangeIMD Smart City Index 2025:ResultsIn 2025 city ranking order and 2024 comparison21IMD Smart City Index 2025IMD Smart City Index 2025City pro

163、filesPRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountryUnited Arab EmiratesHDILife expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanitation meets

164、the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance problems provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesAir pollutio

165、n is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical services provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to effectively monitor air pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments online has impr

166、oved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing Apps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has made public t

167、ransport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic congestion through mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&

168、School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are readily availableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find workMost children have access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOnline servic

169、es provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBusinesses are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliability meet connectivity needsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public access to city f

170、inances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is not an issue of concernOnline voting has increased participationResidents contribute to decision making of local governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResidents provide feedback on local gove

171、rnment projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has reduced waiting times(UN World Urbanization Prospects)1,590,0000.937(Global Data Lab)From a list of 15 indicators,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the percentage of

172、 responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.87.782.379.188.1STRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES75.773.865.749.088.484.759.984.350.569.667.0All ratings rangefrom AAA to D5285.1GROUPATECHNOLOGIESAFACTOR RATINGSASTRUCTURES82.661.8202078.7+0.019+0.5+0.0+0.064.168.883.646.183.8Abu Dhabi74.61 yr change12

173、.767,35312.874,104202120220.91779.217.217.2201910 in 2024Out of 146Out of 14276.169.984.266.678.212.70.86678.917.212.80.89881.183.769,550SMART CITY RANKINGBB in 202482.973.961.871.576.578.872.177.9SMART CITY RATING+4,55372,1310.86079.716.8You are willing to concede personal data in order to improve

174、traffic congestionYou are comfortable with face recognition technologies to lower crimeYou feel the availability of online information has increased your trust in authoritiesThe proportion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)02040608010002040608010071.7%90.9%89

175、.8%69.5%0%20%40%60%80%100%of respondents who agree or strongly agree with the statementScore71.0%50.4%49.0%36.9%28.9%27.9%26.7%25.4%23.3%22.8%19.4%19.1%18.1%15.9%11.9%0%20%40%60%80%100%affordable housingunemploymentfulfilling employmentroad congestionhealth servicesair pollutionpublic transportGreen

176、 spacesrecyclingschool educationbasic amenities(water,waste)citizen engagementsocial mobility/inclusivenesssecuritycorruption/transparency%of respondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreGROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:Abu DhabiPRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATT

177、ITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountryNigeriaHDILife expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanitation meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance problems

178、 provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesAir pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical service

179、s provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to effectively monitor air pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments online has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing A

180、pps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has made public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic congestion t

181、hrough mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are readily av

182、ailableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find workMost children have access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOnline services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBusinesse

183、s are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliability meet connectivity needsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public access to city finances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is not an issue

184、of concernOnline voting has increased participationResidents contribute to decision making of local governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResidents provide feedback on local government projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has reduced waiti

185、ng times(UN World Urbanization Prospects)4,030,0000.678(Global Data Lab)From a list of 15 indicators,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the percentage of responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.71.148.262.563.6S

186、TRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES48.541.932.737.152.752.631.358.644.358.946.4All ratings rangefrom AAA to D133452.3GROUPCTECHNOLOGIESDFACTOR RATINGSCSTRUCTURES52.745.2202052.7+0.002+1.0+0.0+0.039.068.971.524.263.7Abuja37.81 yr change7.44,6857.64,755202120220.53053.610.510.52019135 in 2024Out of 146Out of 14267.

187、541.164.732.841.97.20.52652.910.37.60.52852.952.34,716SMART CITY RANKINGD in 202448.330.819.733.753.557.447.458.4SMART CITY RATING+394,9140.52052.910.1You are willing to concede personal data in order to improve traffic congestionYou are comfortable with face recognition technologies to lower crimeY

188、ou feel the availability of online information has increased your trust in authoritiesThe proportion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)02040608010002040608010074.4%86.6%64.5%66.3%0%20%40%60%80%100%of respondents who agree or strongly agree with the statementS

189、core75.9%70.0%64.7%53.6%50.8%41.4%27.2%24.0%19.0%16.8%14.2%10.2%9.0%7.2%5.0%0%20%40%60%80%100%securityaffordable housingunemploymentcorruption/transparencyhealth servicesbasic amenities(water,waste)fulfilling employmentschool educationpublic transportroad congestioncitizen engagementair pollutionsoc

190、ial mobility/inclusivenessrecyclingGreen spaces%of respondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreGROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:AbujaPRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountryGhanaHDILife expectancy

191、 at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanitation meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance problems provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows residents t

192、o easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesAir pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical services provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to effectively monitor air pollution

193、Finding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments online has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing Apps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an available p

194、arking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has made public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic congestion through mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing of tickets

195、 to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are readily availableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find workMost children have access to

196、a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOnline services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBusinesses are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliability meet connectivity needsMinoriti

197、es feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public access to city finances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is not an issue of concernOnline voting has increased participationResidents contribute to decision making of loc

198、al governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResidents provide feedback on local government projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has reduced waiting times(UN World Urbanization Prospects)2,720,0000.670(Global Data Lab)From a list of 15 indicat

199、ors,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the percentage of responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.67.828.249.753.5STRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES37.126.624.223.556.453.319.249.018.849.531.3All ratings rangefrom AAA to D14

200、1444.7GROUPDTECHNOLOGIESDFACTOR RATINGSDSTRUCTURES44.732.2202063.8+0.004+0.1+0.0+0.043.749.273.028.046.1Accra23.81 yr change6.45,3056.45,380202120220.58963.911.611.62019138 in 2024Out of 146Out of 14257.846.360.936.635.26.30.58664.111.46.40.58552.841.45,279SMART CITY RANKINGD in 202448.522.414.222.6

201、50.054.640.650.4SMART CITY RATING+1025,1210.58664.711.3You are willing to concede personal data in order to improve traffic congestionYou are comfortable with face recognition technologies to lower crimeYou feel the availability of online information has increased your trust in authoritiesThe propor

202、tion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)02040608010002040608010074.5%87.0%56.8%60.8%0%20%40%60%80%100%of respondents who agree or strongly agree with the statementScore71.1%63.6%58.4%52.4%51.2%36.8%35.3%31.9%24.4%23.2%16.4%13.8%6.4%6.1%4.0%0%20%40%60%80%100%un

203、employmentaffordable housingbasic amenities(water,waste)health servicescorruption/transparencysecurityroad congestionfulfilling employmentair pollutionschool educationrecyclingpublic transportcitizen engagementsocial mobility/inclusivenessGreen spaces%of respondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreG

204、ROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:PRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountrySaudi ArabiaHDILife expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHe

205、alth&SafetyBasic sanitation meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance problems provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved a

206、ccess to city servicesAir pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical services provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to effectively monitor air pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging me

207、dical appointments online has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing Apps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling

208、and ticket sales has made public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic congestion through mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)a

209、re satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are readily availableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find workMost children have access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided

210、by local institutionsOnline services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBusinesses are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliability meet connectivity needsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily access

211、ibleOnline public access to city finances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is not an issue of concernOnline voting has increased participationResidents contribute to decision making of local governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeReside

212、nts provide feedback on local government projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has reduced waiting times(Census)410,0000.862(Global Data Lab)From a list of 15 indicators,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the percen

213、tage of responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.78.865.068.874.5STRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES73.669.445.435.572.184.056.185.537.158.865.7All ratings rangefrom AAA to D61378.8GROUPBTECHNOLOGIESBFACTOR RATINGSBSTRUCTURES60.456.3202076.9+0.007+1.0+0.0+0.052.963.372.753.669.5Al-Khobar58.91 yr

214、change11.345,56311.350,620202120220.85677.915.215.2201999 in 2024Out of 146Out of 14269.564.582.658.666.710.90.84676.215.211.30.84974.266.747,441SMART CITY RANKINGCCC in 202481.966.249.467.278.870.372.771.8SMART CITY RATING+3,17947,5290.84277.315.0You are willing to concede personal data in order to

215、 improve traffic congestionYou are comfortable with face recognition technologies to lower crimeYou feel the availability of online information has increased your trust in authoritiesThe proportion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)02040608010002040608010051.

216、5%84.9%82.3%70.5%0%20%40%60%80%100%of respondents who agree or strongly agree with the statementScore60.0%50.7%46.5%32.8%32.1%31.2%30.8%28.6%28.6%21.2%16.4%15.7%14.8%12.2%11.8%0%20%40%60%80%100%affordable housingroad congestionunemploymentair pollutionGreen spacesfulfilling employmentrecyclinghealth

217、 servicesbasic amenities(water,waste)public transportcorruption/transparencysecuritycitizen engagementschool educationsocial mobility/inclusiveness%of respondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreGROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:PRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATT

218、ITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountryAlgeriaHDILife expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanitation meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance problems

219、 provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesAir pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical service

220、s provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to effectively monitor air pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments online has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing A

221、pps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has made public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic congestion t

222、hrough mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are readily av

223、ailableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find workMost children have access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOnline services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBusinesse

224、s are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliability meet connectivity needsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public access to city finances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is not an issue

225、of concernOnline voting has increased participationResidents contribute to decision making of local governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResidents provide feedback on local government projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has reduced waiti

226、ng times(UN World Urbanization Prospects)2,950,0000.766(Global Data Lab)From a list of 15 indicators,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the percentage of responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.53.146.057.656.6S

227、TRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES46.542.138.635.960.655.935.955.119.152.250.3All ratings rangefrom AAA to D128455.2GROUPCTECHNOLOGIESCFACTOR RATINGSCSTRUCTURES41.535.7202076.4+0.002+0.8+0.1+0.055.043.354.535.657.5Algiers42.91 yr change7.010,6357.010,978202120220.74077.115.515.42019124 in 2024Out of 146Out of 14

228、258.246.166.141.845.67.00.73874.515.37.00.73857.846.110,823SMART CITY RANKINGC in 202451.839.128.341.161.759.364.149.1SMART CITY RATING+15511,3540.73676.515.2You are willing to concede personal data in order to improve traffic congestionYou are comfortable with face recognition technologies to lower

229、 crimeYou feel the availability of online information has increased your trust in authoritiesThe proportion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)02040608010002040608010054.9%78.7%70.7%53.6%0%20%40%60%80%100%of respondents who agree or strongly agree with the sta

230、tementScore60.8%48.4%44.6%38.7%38.7%38.0%31.6%30.4%28.2%27.4%23.7%20.8%19.4%13.8%6.3%0%20%40%60%80%100%unemploymentaffordable housinghealth servicescorruption/transparencyroad congestionbasic amenities(water,waste)fulfilling employmentpublic transportsecurityGreen spacesair pollutionschool education

231、recyclingcitizen engagementsocial mobility/inclusiveness%of respondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreGROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:PRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountrySaudi ArabiaHDILife

232、 expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanitation meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance problems provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows

233、residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesAir pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical services provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to effectively monitor ai

234、r pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments online has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing Apps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an

235、available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has made public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic congestion through mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing

236、 of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are readily availableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find workMost children have

237、 access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOnline services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBusinesses are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliability meet connectivity ne

238、edsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public access to city finances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is not an issue of concernOnline voting has increased participationResidents contribute to decision ma

239、king of local governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResidents provide feedback on local government projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has reduced waiting times(Census)60,0000.871(Global Data Lab)From a list of 15 indicators,survey respon

240、dents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the percentage of responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.72.937.464.443.5STRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES45.941.545.640.865.047.337.772.348.052.661.3All ratings rangefrom AAA to D112360.7GROUPCCTECH

241、NOLOGIESCCFACTOR RATINGSCCSTRUCTURES51.729.1202076.9+0.007+1.0+0.0+0.045.538.064.722.045.6AlUla14.91 yr change11.345,56311.350,620202120220.85677.915.215.22019not in 2024Out of 14648.139.171.938.342.610.90.84676.215.211.30.84973.554.947,441SMART CITY RANKINGnot in 202459.345.933.751.664.949.159.153.

242、3SMART CITY RATING+3,17947,5290.84277.315.0You are willing to concede personal data in order to improve traffic congestionYou are comfortable with face recognition technologies to lower crimeYou feel the availability of online information has increased your trust in authoritiesThe proportion of your

243、 day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)02040608010002040608010039.0%86.7%90.8%70.4%0%20%40%60%80%100%of respondents who agree or strongly agree with the statementScore80.5%60.5%60.0%37.9%30.8%19.5%19.0%7.2%6.2%4.6%4.6%3.6%2.6%2.6%1.5%0%20%40%60%80%100%affordable housingh

244、ealth servicesunemploymentbasic amenities(water,waste)school educationpublic transportroad congestionair pollutionsecurityrecyclingfulfilling employmentcitizen engagementGreen spacessocial mobility/inclusivenesscorruption/transparency%of respondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreGROUP MEANCITYLEGE

245、ND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:PRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountryJordanHDILife expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanita

246、tion meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance problems provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesA

247、ir pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical services provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to effectively monitor air pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments onli

248、ne has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing Apps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has ma

249、de public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic congestion through mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportun

250、ities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are readily availableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find workMost children have access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOn

251、line services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBusinesses are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliability meet connectivity needsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public acces

252、s to city finances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is not an issue of concernOnline voting has increased participationResidents contribute to decision making of local governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResidents provide feedback on

253、 local government projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has reduced waiting times(UN Data)4,010,0000.753(Global Data Lab)From a list of 15 indicators,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the percentage of responses pe

254、r area,the greater the priority for the city.65.058.162.969.6STRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES55.350.138.029.372.162.837.866.116.151.056.6All ratings rangefrom AAA to D127463.1GROUPCTECHNOLOGIESCFACTOR RATINGSCSTRUCTURES47.232.0202074.3-0.002-0.0+0.0+0.043.435.559.132.642.1Amman51.11 yr change10.49,18310.49,29

255、5202120220.74274.212.612.62019128 in 2024Out of 146Out of 14261.838.371.833.747.010.40.74075.212.610.40.74459.047.49,180SMART CITY RANKINGD in 202462.743.123.147.351.252.342.957.5SMART CITY RATING+1159,5570.73876.012.5You are willing to concede personal data in order to improve traffic congestionYou

256、 are comfortable with face recognition technologies to lower crimeYou feel the availability of online information has increased your trust in authoritiesThe proportion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)02040608010002040608010052.0%86.2%66.6%54.1%0%20%40%60%80

257、%100%of respondents who agree or strongly agree with the statementScore66.5%62.3%61.2%40.1%37.7%31.7%30.0%29.6%26.0%24.7%20.5%19.6%13.3%8.7%7.1%0%20%40%60%80%100%unemploymentroad congestionaffordable housingfulfilling employmentcorruption/transparencybasic amenities(water,waste)Green spaceshealth se

258、rvicesair pollutionpublic transportrecyclingschool educationsecuritycitizen engagementsocial mobility/inclusiveness%of respondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreGROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:PRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design

259、 CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountryNetherlandsHDILife expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanitation meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance problems provides a speedy solutionR

260、ecycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesAir pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical services provision is satisfactoryA

261、 website or App allows residents to effectively monitor air pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments online has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing Apps have reduced congestionP

262、ublic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has made public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic congestion through mobile phonesActiviti

263、esActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are readily availableOnline access to job

264、listings has made it easier to find workMost children have access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOnline services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBusinesses are creating new jobsThe c

265、urrent internet speed and reliability meet connectivity needsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public access to city finances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is not an issue of concernOnline voting has

266、increased participationResidents contribute to decision making of local governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResidents provide feedback on local government projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has reduced waiting times(UN World Urbanizati

267、on Prospects)1,180,0000.964(Global Data Lab)From a list of 15 indicators,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the percentage of responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.76.355.666.672.1STRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES47.960.

268、255.138.158.169.843.768.027.441.653.6All ratings rangefrom AAA to D17158.2GROUPATECHNOLOGIESAAFACTOR RATINGSAASTRUCTURES59.270.7202081.7+0.003+0.8+0.0+0.044.166.281.820.658.0Amsterdam51.01 yr change12.652,50012.657,278202120220.93982.518.618.6201918 in 2024Out of 146Out of 14274.760.059.952.051.812.

269、50.93381.618.412.60.93661.162.455,355SMART CITY RANKINGA in 202459.745.145.754.473.455.163.456.1SMART CITY RATING+1,92355,6280.93282.018.4You are willing to concede personal data in order to improve traffic congestionYou are comfortable with face recognition technologies to lower crimeYou feel the a

270、vailability of online information has increased your trust in authoritiesThe proportion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)02040608010002040608010059.2%61.9%62.7%73.8%0%20%40%60%80%100%of respondents who agree or strongly agree with the statementScore75.5%55.8

271、%39.9%39.2%32.9%32.2%28.4%24.8%23.0%22.6%20.4%17.8%16.0%13.2%10.3%0%20%40%60%80%100%affordable housingsecurityhealth servicespublic transportroad congestionbasic amenities(water,waste)Green spacesair pollutionschool educationunemploymentcitizen engagementsocial mobility/inclusivenessrecyclingfulfill

272、ing employmentcorruption/transparency%of respondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreGROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:PRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountryTrkiyeHDILife expectancy at birthExpec

273、ted years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanitation meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance problems provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to easily give

274、away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesAir pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical services provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to effectively monitor air pollutionFinding housin

275、g with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments online has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing Apps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an available parking space h

276、ave reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has made public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic congestion through mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing of tickets to shows and

277、museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are readily availableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find workMost children have access to a good schoolI

278、T skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOnline services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBusinesses are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliability meet connectivity needsMinorities feel welcom

279、eGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public access to city finances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is not an issue of concernOnline voting has increased participationResidents contribute to decision making of local governmentA

280、n online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResidents provide feedback on local government projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has reduced waiting times(UN World Urbanization Prospects)5,480,0000.871(Global Data Lab)From a list of 15 indicators,survey res

281、pondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the percentage of responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.73.373.262.665.7STRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES58.559.640.139.266.558.750.269.125.639.543.9All ratings rangefrom AAA to D98368.1GROUPCCCT

282、ECHNOLOGIESCCCFACTOR RATINGSCCCSTRUCTURES48.559.8202076.0+0.005+2.4+0.0+0.058.152.563.527.051.1Ankara62.81 yr change8.828,3818.832,834202120220.83878.519.719.7201996 in 2024Out of 146Out of 14268.656.169.551.957.68.60.82675.919.38.80.83354.056.131,310SMART CITY RANKINGCCC in 202466.051.936.544.051.5

283、54.859.356.0SMART CITY RATING+1,52427,9500.82177.819.2You are willing to concede personal data in order to improve traffic congestionYou are comfortable with face recognition technologies to lower crimeYou feel the availability of online information has increased your trust in authoritiesThe proport

284、ion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)02040608010002040608010059.2%70.6%61.2%70.3%0%20%40%60%80%100%of respondents who agree or strongly agree with the statementScore73.6%48.4%47.7%34.6%31.5%29.7%28.8%28.5%27.3%25.8%25.4%23.6%21.3%8.5%5.2%0%20%40%60%80%100%af

285、fordable housingroad congestionunemploymentGreen spacesfulfilling employmentpublic transportcorruption/transparencyhealth servicesair pollutionsecurityschool educationbasic amenities(water,waste)recyclingcitizen engagementsocial mobility/inclusiveness%of respondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreG

286、ROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:PRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountryKazakhstanHDILife expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHeal

287、th&SafetyBasic sanitation meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance problems provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved acc

288、ess to city servicesAir pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical services provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to effectively monitor air pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medi

289、cal appointments online has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing Apps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling an

290、d ticket sales has made public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic congestion through mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are

291、 satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are readily availableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find workMost children have access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by

292、 local institutionsOnline services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBusinesses are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliability meet connectivity needsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessib

293、leOnline public access to city finances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is not an issue of concernOnline voting has increased participationResidents contribute to decision making of local governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResident

294、s provide feedback on local government projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has reduced waiting times(UN World Urbanization Prospects)1,320,0000.816(Global Data Lab)From a list of 15 indicators,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their c

295、ity.The higher the percentage of responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.80.460.978.059.2STRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES58.753.455.837.061.160.946.175.843.048.656.5All ratings rangefrom AAA to D102361.8GROUPCCTECHNOLOGIESCCCFACTOR RATINGSCCSTRUCTURES67.667.4202069.4+0.002+0.1+0.0+0.053.661.8

296、73.237.965.0Astana50.51 yr change12.423,30412.422,587202120220.80469.514.814.82019not in 2024Out of 14672.553.475.143.053.412.30.79770.014.812.40.80249.055.122,602SMART CITY RANKINGnot in 202459.944.434.151.964.064.069.667.9SMART CITY RATING-1522,7870.79971.614.6You are willing to concede personal d

297、ata in order to improve traffic congestionYou are comfortable with face recognition technologies to lower crimeYou feel the availability of online information has increased your trust in authoritiesThe proportion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)020406080100

298、02040608010049.3%68.1%58.0%73.6%0%20%40%60%80%100%of respondents who agree or strongly agree with the statementScore66.7%56.5%40.6%39.1%36.2%34.8%34.8%31.9%27.5%21.7%15.9%15.9%13.0%10.1%8.7%0%20%40%60%80%100%corruption/transparencyaffordable housingair pollutionbasic amenities(water,waste)securityre

299、cyclingroad congestionfulfilling employmentunemploymenthealth servicesGreen spacessocial mobility/inclusivenesscitizen engagementpublic transportschool education%of respondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreGROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:PRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPop

300、ulation HDIATTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountryGreeceHDILife expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanitation meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city mainten

301、ance problems provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesAir pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMe

302、dical services provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to effectively monitor air pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments online has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problem

303、Car-sharing Apps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has made public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic

304、 congestion through mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services a

305、re readily availableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find workMost children have access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOnline services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new busi

306、nessBusinesses are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliability meet connectivity needsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public access to city finances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is

307、not an issue of concernOnline voting has increased participationResidents contribute to decision making of local governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResidents provide feedback on local government projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has

308、reduced waiting times(UN World Urbanization Prospects)3,150,0000.918(Global Data Lab)From a list of 15 indicators,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the percentage of responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.78.4

309、53.459.952.7STRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES46.461.237.820.339.131.535.562.811.536.541.3All ratings rangefrom AAA to D129251.8GROUPCCCTECHNOLOGIESCCCFACTOR RATINGSCCCSTRUCTURES27.841.9202080.1+0.006+0.5+0.0+0.026.342.169.715.631.1Athens41.11 yr change11.426,97311.431,382202120220.88680.620.020.02019120 in 202

310、4Out of 146Out of 14266.740.673.623.933.411.10.87780.919.711.40.88036.540.729,421SMART CITY RANKINGC in 202439.931.021.042.940.543.341.949.5SMART CITY RATING+1,96029,4570.88181.219.7You are willing to concede personal data in order to improve traffic congestionYou are comfortable with face recogniti

311、on technologies to lower crimeYou feel the availability of online information has increased your trust in authoritiesThe proportion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)02040608010002040608010055.7%57.5%45.7%66.2%0%20%40%60%80%100%of respondents who agree or str

312、ongly agree with the statementScore55.5%54.8%52.4%47.1%40.4%36.7%31.0%27.4%24.7%21.6%21.6%21.5%16.6%6.5%6.5%0%20%40%60%80%100%securityhealth servicesaffordable housingroad congestionunemploymentcorruption/transparencyGreen spacesair pollutionbasic amenities(water,waste)school educationpublic transpo

313、rtfulfilling employmentrecyclingcitizen engagementsocial mobility/inclusiveness%of respondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreGROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:PRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCou

314、ntryNew ZealandHDILife expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of schoolingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanitation meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance problems provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA

315、website or App allows residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesAir pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical services provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to

316、effectively monitor air pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a monthly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments online has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing Apps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps

317、that direct you to an available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has made public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic congestion through mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfa

318、ctoryOnline purchasing of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCultural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are readily availableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find

319、workMost children have access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifelong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOnline services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBusinesses are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliabilit

320、y meet connectivity needsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public access to city finances has reduced corruptionCorruption of city officials is not an issue of concernOnline voting has increased participationResidents con

321、tribute to decision making of local governmentAn online platform where residents can propose ideas has improved city lifeResidents provide feedback on local government projectsProcessing Identification Documents online has reduced waiting times(UN World Urbanization Prospects)1,690,0000.968(Global D

322、ata Lab)From a list of 15 indicators,survey respondents were asked to select 5 that they perceived as the most urgent for their city.The higher the percentage of responses per area,the greater the priority for the city.80.154.454.273.9STRUCTURESTECHNOLOGIES49.462.438.155.153.151.735.865.013.937.942.

323、9All ratings rangefrom AAA to D25165.5GROUPATECHNOLOGIESAAFACTOR RATINGSASTRUCTURES37.864.3202082.5+0.001+0.6+0.0+0.041.952.374.621.767.8Auckland57.71 yr change12.941,22512.943,665202120220.93683.019.719.7201931 in 2024Out of 146Out of 14272.060.562.950.547.013.00.93582.719.212.90.93557.173.042,850S

324、MART CITY RANKINGBBB in 202457.640.452.056.467.854.363.648.9SMART CITY RATING+81642,2100.93382.619.5You are willing to concede personal data in order to improve traffic congestionYou are comfortable with face recognition technologies to lower crimeYou feel the availability of online information has

325、increased your trust in authoritiesThe proportion of your day-to-day payment transactions that are non-cash(%of transactions)02040608010002040608010068.4%74.7%59.4%80.1%0%20%40%60%80%100%of respondents who agree or strongly agree with the statementScore83.1%63.0%53.3%44.3%42.5%39.9%27.3%21.6%21.3%13

326、.7%13.3%9.6%9.1%8.4%7.1%0%20%40%60%80%100%affordable housingroad congestionhealth servicessecurityunemploymentpublic transportfulfilling employmentschool educationbasic amenities(water,waste)corruption/transparencyrecyclingair pollutioncitizen engagementsocial mobility/inclusivenessGreen spaces%of r

327、espondents who chose the Priority AreaScoreGROUP MEANCITYLEGEND:MINGROUP MAXCITYMEANLEGEND:PRIORITY AREASBACKGROUND INFORMATIONCityPopulation HDIATTITUDESMap tiles by Stamen Design CC BY 3.0 Map Data OpenStreetMapCountryThailandHDILife expectancy at birthExpected years of schoolingMean years of scho

328、olingGNI per capita(PPP$)Health&SafetyHealth&SafetyBasic sanitation meets the needs of the poorest areasOnline reporting of city maintenance problems provides a speedy solutionRecycling services are satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to easily give away unwanted itemsPublic safety is not

329、a problemFree public wifi has improved access to city servicesAir pollution is not a problemCCTV cameras has made residents feel saferMedical services provision is satisfactoryA website or App allows residents to effectively monitor air pollutionFinding housing with rent equal to 30%or less of a mon

330、thly salary is not a problemArranging medical appointments online has improved accessMobilityMobilityTraffic congestion is not a problemCar-sharing Apps have reduced congestionPublic transport is satisfactoryApps that direct you to an available parking space have reduced journey time Bicycle hiring

331、has reduced congestionOnline scheduling and ticket sales has made public transport easier to useThe city provides information on traffic congestion through mobile phonesActivitiesActivitiesGreen spaces are satisfactoryOnline purchasing of tickets to shows and museums has made it easier to attendCult

332、ural activities(shows,bars,and museums)are satisfactoryOpportunities(Work&School)Opportunities(Work&School)Employment finding services are readily availableOnline access to job listings has made it easier to find workMost children have access to a good schoolIT skills are taught well in schoolsLifel

333、ong learning opportunities are provided by local institutionsOnline services provided by the city has made it easier to start a new businessBusinesses are creating new jobsThe current internet speed and reliability meet connectivity needsMinorities feel welcomeGovernanceGovernanceInformation on local government decisions are easily accessibleOnline public access to city finances has reduced corrup